Log In | Sign Up Now | Help & Support
Need Advice? Ask Your Question

Questions & Answers

Category: Baby Gear

Asked by momtobe1992

Q: electric or manual breast pump?

I'm debating over an electric breast pump or a manual one. I will be a stay at home mom. I won't be breast-feeding in public, if I have to feed the baby, I will be feeding him in the car. For those that have a manual pump, does it take a really long time to fill up a bottle of milk, does your hand get tired? I want my Dh to feed the baby too so I want to pump at least 2 times a day. I'm going more towards the manual right now. But just wanted to know what other mommy's thoughts are. :)

This question was asked Nov. 24, 2012 1:22am
Category: Baby Gear

Answer This Question
Answered by LilianaBaum - Mar. 10, 2015 9:48am
Well recommendations might be different of every individuals, hence choices is all yours. Electric breast pumps are only good if you know how to control their vacuum and cycles or else it would be better to go with a manual one. Suppliers like http://www.ilexmedical.com/ and others can provide both types of breast pumps; you should choose one that feels comfortable to your breast and your baby.

Here is the pros and cons of both types of pumps:

Manual pump pros:

a. Cost effective
b. More discreet
c. Easy to use
d. Comfortable

Manual pump cons:

A. Requires manual efforts.
B. Needs more time than electric one.

Electric pump pros:

A. Quick and automatic.
B. Doesn’t require much effort.

Electric pump cons:

A. Expensive replacement parts.
B. Consume electricity.

145 out of 281 found this answer helpful
Was this answer helpful?  YesNo


Answered by momtobe1992 - Nov. 24, 2012 2:29pm
thanks ladies, I will definitely look more into the electric Medela pump

152 out of 330 found this answer helpful
Was this answer helpful?  YesNo


Answered by TigerLilly0930 - Nov. 24, 2012 1:03pm
I HIGHLY reccomend an electric breast pump. I have one of each (the manual one I purchased prior to giving birth thinking that since my plan was to exclusively nurse, I would have it incase of an emergency)...and the electric one was purchased after I brought my daughter home when I realized that I didn't want to nurse after she was 4 weeks old. She is now 7 weeks old, and I've been exclusively pumping for the last 3 1/2 weeks...I am also a stay at home mom. I find the electric pump to be faster, easier to use and less tiring. It's so much easier to just connect to for those middle of the night pumping sessions as well. Things dont always go as planned, and sometimes exclusive nursing does not work out for whatever reason...it's good to have options so that you don't get overwhelmed. :)
You can probably rent one from the hospital that you are delivering at (the one I delivered at offered a rental service for $60/month), or you can invest in a good one for about $150. GL!!! :)

178 out of 350 found this answer helpful
Was this answer helpful?  YesNo


Answered by zaiobaio - Nov. 24, 2012 9:27am
With my first child I bought manual breast pump , but Im not very happy...Every time took me around 30 min to express enough milk and my hand was always so tired .... Im also stay at home mom and Im planing to breast feed again ... but this time bought electric breast pump .I ve made research and I think the best for me is Medela . It is a bit expensive but worth it.

171 out of 354 found this answer helpful
Was this answer helpful?  YesNo


Answered by a member - Nov. 24, 2012 6:33am
Call your insurance company. Many insurance companies are covering breast pumps. My insurance fully covered any breast pump I wanted.

173 out of 344 found this answer helpful
Was this answer helpful?  YesNo


Answered by momtobe1992 - Nov. 24, 2012 3:46am
thanks ladies, I'll definitely look into a electric pump then. since it's pricy, I'll buy a used one and sanitize it. :)

173 out of 347 found this answer helpful
Was this answer helpful?  YesNo


Answered by tibby8 - Nov. 24, 2012 3:32am
I invested in a manual pump thinking it wouldn't be a hassle and portable...its awful lol your hand definitely gets tired and idk about other moms but my flow of milk isn't fast so it takes like 30 mins to get like an ounce. I rented an electric pump and its made pumping so easy. Its a quarter of the time and when baby is hungry, you don't have time to pump manually to have enough to satisfy them. That's just my experience. (:

163 out of 341 found this answer helpful
Was this answer helpful?  YesNo


Answered by estone - Nov. 24, 2012 2:18am
Electric is so much easier!

159 out of 344 found this answer helpful
Was this answer helpful?  YesNo


Answer This Question

You are not logged in.
Log in or Register to post an answer to this question.